The Future of Organic Search Discoverability: Key Insights from Industry Leaders

Replay of webinar from Thursday, January 16, 2025
In a recent Knotch webinar, one of our founding partners, Brent Bouldin, joined Matt Cardwell (former head of content and organic search at Rocket Mortgage) and Kevin Indig (former head of search at Shopify) to delve into the future of search and how the rapidly evolving landscape impacts enterprise marketing leaders.

A New Reality for Search Strategy

Search is no longer confined to Google. AI-driven platforms, YouTube, and even TikTok are rapidly changing how users discover content. These shifts demand a fundamental rethinking of how brands approach audience engagement.

Kevin Indig pointed out that search is evolving from keywords to conversations. AI interfaces like ChatGPT allow users to ask long, specific questions—and get detailed answers. For marketing leaders, this creates opportunities to address niche user needs but requires a new level of sophistication in content strategy.

The Quality Imperative

“Google is no longer evaluating pages in isolation. It’s evaluating domains as a whole,” shared Indig, referring to Google’s 2023 helpful content update. Companies that compromise quality in pursuit of quantity risk significant penalties.

This calls for stronger content governance across large organizations. Quality, as Brent observed, is not just about meeting Google’s criteria but understanding and answering customer questions comprehensively.

User Behavior and the Evolution of Search Intent

Users increasingly start their searches with conversational queries or on platforms like TikTok. However, Matt cautioned against abandoning traditional search: “Discovery might start elsewhere, but high-consideration purchases still come back to search.”

This evolution means brands must develop content strategies that cater to each stage of the customer journey—from curiosity on TikTok to decision-making on Google.

The Death of Linear Customer Journeys

“The funnel is deader now than it ever was,” Brent remarked, illustrating how customers zigzag between platforms. For example, a discovery on Instagram might lead to further research on YouTube or Google.

Marketing leaders must move beyond rigid funnels and embrace multi-channel strategies. To maximize effectiveness, teams need seamless integration between their search, content, and social strategies.

Measurement and Attribution Challenges

Traditional attribution models struggle to account for search’s influence across the customer journey. Cardwell noted, “You’re probably missing 30% of search’s overall impact.” A more holistic view of analytics—tying search performance to business outcomes—is critical for smarter resource allocation.

Strategic Implications for Marketing Leaders

The panel discussion revealed actionable insights for marketing teams:

  • Embrace a Multi-Channel Strategy: View search as one part of a broader discoverability strategy, incorporating platforms like YouTube and TikTok.
  • Prioritize Content Quality: Invest in well-researched, high-quality content that reflects user intent and builds domain authority.
  • Experiment Strategically: Allocate 20% of your budget to exploring new platforms and approaches.
  • Leverage Paid Search as a Testing Ground:  Use paid campaigns to validate ideas before rolling them out organically.
  • Adopt AI Thoughtfully:  Incorporate AI tools to improve efficiency but keep customer needs at the forefront.

Looking Ahead

While search is evolving, one principle remains constant: understanding and serving customer intent is the cornerstone of success. For marketing leaders, the challenge is balancing new platforms and technologies with tried-and-true strategies.

Tom Dwyer
Tom Dwyer is a Principal Advisor at New Media Advisors. Before joining New Media Advisors, Tom held leadership roles at several high-profile companies such as LexisNexis and Bank of America, where he consistently delivered impressive results. His unique blend of strategic thinking, technical acumen, and a customer-centric approach has been instrumental in driving transformational growth.

Special Offer:

Schedule a complimentary 30-minute consultation with one of our Senior Advisors and leave the meeting with 3 custom SEO actions your brand can deploy immediately. No strings attached.

Marketing  Insights